Who Replaced Heidi Klum on 'AGT'? The Judge Was Absent for Health Reasons

July 2024 · 5 minute read

Fans were confused — and a bit worried — when one of the show's judges was absent on Season 15. But who replaced Heidi Klum on 'AGT'?

Source: Getty Images

Heidi Klum has been a familiar face on America's Got Talent ever since Season 8 of the reality competition series. She's a fair, but firm presence on the NBC show — not to mention, the fashion guru has brought along her decent-sized fan base thanks from her modeling and Project Runway days.

So you can imagine how concerned viewers were when instead of seeing Heidi next to Simon Cowell, Sofia Vergara, and Howie Mandel halfway through the June 16 episode of AGT, there was someone else entirely. But who replaced Heidi in Season 15? Let's take a deep dive into the unique situation.

Source: Instagram

Who replaced Heidi in 'AGT'?

On June 16, fans took notice when, instead of Heidi sitting next to Simon, Sofia, and Howie, someone else was sitting in her chair about halfway through the episode. The audition episodes were filmed in early March 2020, right around when the novel coronavirus started impacting the U.S. in big ways.

Wait Heidi seriously didn’t show up for the second half? Wow. #agt #AmericasGotTalent

— Cupcake & coconut (mall) girl 🧁 🥥 (@Cupcakegirl013) June 17, 2020 Source: Twitter

Evidently, Heidi wasn't feeling well and ended up leaving mid-show because of it. With only a fews hours of notice, one of her friends was able to step in and temporarily replace the sick judge.

View this post on Instagram

Oh we've got a treat for you! @ericstonestreet joins @sofiavergara, @howiemandel, and @simoncowell on an all-new #AGT TUESDAY 8/7c on @nbc!

A post shared by America's Got Talent - AGT (@agt) on Jun 21, 2020 at 7:00pm PDT

Source: Instagram

Heidi's replacement was none other than Eric Stonestreet, who played Cameron Tucker on Modern Family. In mid-June, Heidi took to Instagram to give a shoutout to Eric for coming to the rescue on such short notice.

"From Modern Family to the @AGT Family," she captioned a photo of Eric sitting in front of a mirror in a chair with "Heidi" written on it. "Thank you @ericstonestreet for filling in for me when I was home sick."

View this post on Instagram

From Modern Family to the @AGT Family ❤️ Thank you @ericstonestreet for filling in for me when I was home sick. New episode of #AGT starts now on @nbc!

A post shared by Heidi Klum (@heidiklum) on Jun 23, 2020 at 4:59pm PDT

Source: Instagram

Wait, did Heidi Klum have COVID-19?

When Heidi didn't return for the next episode of AGT either, fans began to wonder if Eric was permanently replacing her and if the judge was OK.

"When I fell ill, it was on March 10. I was experiencing fever and sore throat, so I told production and immediately the medic did my vitals and said, 'Yes, you have a fever,' and then I was dismissed," Heidi told People in May.

"It felt strange to leave, but that was the right thing to do," she added. "I told them how I was feeling. They looked at me, checked me out and said, 'Yeah, go home.' Then I was asked to get tested ASAP so that I could go back to work because we didn't know that this was all unfolding the way it did. They were like, 'Okay, get tested as fast as you can.'"

Source: Instagram

Although it took Heidi quite a while to obtain a COVID-19 test — and then even longer for the results — the AGT star ultimately tested negative for the novel coronavirus. Heidi updated her Instagram followers on March 24, writing, "Day 14 of staying HOME," alongside the hashtag #covid_19negative.

Still, Heidi and her husband, Tom Kaulitz, ended up quarantining apart for a while after that because he returned from a business trip feeling unwell. (Which was definitely a good call, in our opinion.)

View this post on Instagram

Like many of you, I also have been sick all week and, unfortunately, my husband who returned from his tour a couple of days ago is also feeling ill. To be safe, we are staying apart until we get the results of our Coronavirus tests (that we were finally able to get today) back. We don’t want to spread germs and risk others getting sicker... even each other! As much as I want to embrace him and kiss him, it is more important to do the right thing and not spread further. ❤️ These are strange times... but in these moments, you remember what’s really important- the people you love and keeping them safe. Social distancing is what we all need to do right now to be responsible citizens of the world. We are all in this together and it is up to us to protect our loved ones, and our neighbors and our communities. Please listen to the officials and stay at home if you can and physically distance yourself from other people… especially if you are not feeling well. I see all the beautiful things people are doing for each other all over the globe and that gives me hope! Sending all of you love and positivity and healing vibes… together we can get through this but we need to be proactive so that we can all have a bright and healthy future. 🥰😷✌🏻🧼❤️ #socialdistancing #washyourhands #stayput #bekindtoeachother

A post shared by Heidi Klum (@heidiklum) on Mar 14, 2020 at 7:02pm PDT

Source: Instagram

Although Heidi now seems to be in perfect health, Eric will be replacing her again on AGT on June 30, as he revealed via Instagram ahead of the audition episode airing.

"Hey all. I’ll be back tonight for my second and final time on @agt," he wrote. "This was taped 3 months ago. Thanks again for having me. It was an absolute blast and pleasure to do it."

Source: Instagram

So yeah. The good news is that Eric Stonestreet replacing Heidi Klum on AGT isn't a permanent thing (though we have to admit, he's done an amazing job filling in) and that Heidi will be back on the show before you know it. 

Be sure to catch America's Got Talent Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET on NBC.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7pbXSramam6Ses7p6wqikaKhfrLWwedGep6WZk5qxbrTEopuiZZuhwq55zqdkmp%2Bk